Pattern: Perfect Pie Shawl by Veronique Avery, from Weekend Knitting
Yarn: Elann Pure Alpaca in Jasper, 4.5 balls
Needles: US 10
Notes: This was an easy and quick pattern. Other than the yarn sub, it was made without alterations. There is an error in the pattern, and if you decide to make it you should be sure to twist the stitch on all of your M1s in the lace section. This is the opposite of what the pattern tells you to do, but it will result in a shawl that looks like the one in the book. Other than that, the pattern was error free and fun! I bound off in K2P2 rib, following the pattern, and I think it resulted in a nicer bind-off edge than a plain knit bind off. I do have one problem… I think I might be allergic the the yarn. I haven’t had any skin reaction to it or anything, but it was making me a little stuff while I knit it. I’m not sure if this might be due to the manufacturing process Elann uses, as I have been sensitive to the sizing they use in some of their cotton yarns. I will wait and see if it gets better now that it is blocked. After all, I have made (and frequently worn) an Alpaca sweater before with no problems. It could even be the time of year, as I always have allergies in late July/August. It’s hard to say… I will have to wait until the weather is cold enough to wear the shawl, and see how I feel then!
My shawl turned out maybe a tiny bit smaller than the one in the book, but I have decided for the moment to not add an edging. I don’t really feel like searching for a complimentary yarn, at least not until I see whether I will need to give it away.
Green apples - Stitchywitch Creates 
Beautiful! the color is gorgeous on you. what a versatile shape it is too.
It’s gorgeous. You are so fast! I really hope you turn out not to be allergic to the yarn, because this would be tough to give away.
Hi, I’m a new reader. I just wanted to tell you that your shawl is beautiful! And thanks for the error warning. I don’t have that book, but I had heard it was good.
Can’t wait to see what you do next!
Charli
Another stellar fo! The color is especially good on you…
Nicely done! You make me want to knit it and I have just the yarn for it too!
Great photo shoot especially on the last pose!
Its beautiful!
I love it! It looks very wearable and sophisticated, especially with that pin.
gorgeous! i love it closed with the brooch, very ladylike and lovely.
wow your shawl is stunning. Love the look of the brooch as well.
Sniff. Yours looks great. Mine is still only 4/5ths done and I started it in February. I just find it so boring to knit. I also didn’t find out about the mistake in the pattern until after I’d reached about 2/5ths so mine’s staying as it is.
very nice, i will have to re-look at that pattern because that is a perfect little shawl to wear for those not too cold nights.
Hi ! Your blog is great and you make wonderful things ! This shawl is very very beautiful .
Beautiful! The color looks great!
Beautiful and smart construction!!
It’s beautiful. Maybe you won’t have to give it away.
It is really lovely! Good work.
Beautiful shawl! Looks lovely on you.
I have the book and haven’t been particularly inspired by the shawl. Seeing your finished one makes me want to knit it!!
You look very very lovely. 🙂
Beautiful as always. 🙂 And nice pictures, too!
How lovely! I wouldn’t add an edging. It looks perfect the way it is.
Is really beautiful!!! Don’t think you need the edging, is simple but elegant.
I love it! I agree that the edging isn’t necessary — it’s so simple and unfussy as is.
Oooh, that’s gorgeous! I’m not normally a fan of shawls, and have never been motivated to knit one, but that looks utterly fabulous secured with the brooch. Well done!